We were leaving the Honduran border series of queues and offices, documents in hand that officially cleared us of any further obligation to the country when it hit me hard.
There was a dog, so thin that the bones of her pelvis were so prominent that they completely obscured her genital area. It was hot, even at 10 am, and she was lapping listlessly at a filthy puddle of something that probably contained very little actual water.
I doubt her little doggie life lasted the rest of that day.
It isn’t like I haven’t seen street dogs hours or days from death before. It’s simply a part of life in much of the world. However, after our time in Guatemala and Honduras it was that little dog that broke me, because we all know that when it comes to the impoverished the privileged of the world often tend to focus more on animals than they do people.
I’ve seen the do-gooders. I know some of the do-gooders. And while some do good things to help people it seems that more of them do things to help animals. Shelters, spay and neuter clinics, airline escorts for Mexican and Central American dogs and cats to go to their cushy new homes in the United States or Canada.
All while people are left to lap from the same dirty puddle.
People from all over the world visit Mexico and Central America all the time. They zip line in Costa Rica, frolic on the white sand beaches of Mexico, and dive in the crystal Caribbean waters of Honduras. But more often than not these trips are carefully constructed, staged by tour operators, and guarded by high resort walls. There’s nothing wrong with this; I truly believe everyone should travel and how they do it is their choice.
But what about the things that live outside those tours and walls? What about the people?
I’ve written about this before. Unless you’re a backpacker or overlanding like we are you rarely come into contact with the people who call your dream vacation destination home. Unless they’re mixing your margarita or scraping the callouses from your feet you don’t see them, you don’t ask about their life, and you don’t do these things because you’re on vacation and you deserve to enjoy yourself.
But also, you don’t want to know.
You don’t want to know that your bartender lives in a one room cinder block house. You don’t want to know that the woman carefully polishing your toenails can’t afford to send her kids to school. You don’t want to know that they too suffer, just like the dogs.
I’m as guilty as anyone of turning a blind eye. The simple fact that we can afford to make this trip put us squarely in the middle of the white privilege circle. But even the dead and dying humans on the sidewalks of New Dehli didn’t prepare me for driving the roads of Central America.
I romanticized this trip way too much right from the start. I envisioned wide open beaches, remote jungle villages, and endless adventure. While much of that has been realized too much more of it has not. This is aside from the realization that this mode of travel is really hard. What’s become so difficult for me is passing through these tiny villages, women toeing the edge of the road trying to sell us sacks of unidentifiable food, the desperation so clear on their face as we approach, then the anger when we don’t slow down.
I’ve taken very few photos over the last two months. My instagram feed is bare. That’s not to say that I haven’t wanted to. The haunted and wary eyes of the children that want me to buy gum are definitely photo worthy. These are the types of photos are meant to make you feel something, like the photo of the ash covered, shell shocked Syrian boy on the chair in the hospital. These photos are supposed to make you care.
But you don’t. Or you do but remind yourself how helpless you are and that you have your own problems or children to care for. These are not invalid excuses; we all have our own shit to deal with but the simple fact that we have the option to look away constitutes that white privileged guilt that, well, we’re all pretty much guilty of.
We don’t have to look if we don’t want to.
But on this trip I’ve had to look. Our windows aren’t blacked out, hell, neither are my eyes. There is simply no way not to see the tin and tarp shacks and the barely dressed toddlers in the dirt surrounded by scrawny chickens and heaps of garbage. It’s there, right in front of everybody.
Everybody who looks, that is.
So if you’ve made it this far you might be asking yourself, “Why the hell is she complaining? Why isn’t she doing something?”
I could ask you that same question but you might want to think carefully about your answers.
Do you tip your bartenders and servers in Mexico? Do you buy your ice cream from the man pushing the street cart or do you pop into whatever resembles the local 7-11? Do you avoid a certain city or country because of perceived violence and moan about how great it was in the old days without thinking of the people who have to live there? Do you slip your extra food to a street dog instead of the child who wants desperately to shine your shoes?
I’m not here to shame anyone. Most of the people I know are good people and some of them go above and beyond to serve communities at home and abroad. I’m also not here to set myself apart. I’ve avoided the old man with his hand held out for money, his head held down in shame. I’ve shouted unkind words in Spanish to street kids whose eyes are hardened as they aggressively tell me to buy tortillas after I’ve declined three times.
I sometimes don’t look out the window anymore as we pass through another rural village slapped together from scrap wood and detritus. I don’t see the dull eyes staring at our shiny American vehicle passing through, but I feel them.
I think I’ll feel them for the rest of my life.
Again, I have no answers. You have no answers. Today’s state of affairs around the world has left so many feeling helpless, even those of us in the guilt circle. But one thing we can say as individuals is that I did not do this.
But someone did. Someone left Honduras poverty stricken, someone left Mexico embroiled in violence, someone committed genocide in Guatemala, and someone reduced Syria to an unimaginable and unforgettable photo.
Let’s not mince words here; money rules our world. Corporations are eager to profit from the desperate and governmental officials turn blind eyes but they can certainly feel the money slipped into their dirty hands. Resources are exploited and people are discarded. It happens everywhere, even in your own backyard.
Yet despite everything I’ve said I see people around the world rising up, using their voices, demanding that something resembling humanity be restored in our world. I’ve met people on this trip who fill extra suitcases with medical supplies and books. I know people who live as expats yet do amazing things in their communities to help the local populations. The human ones.
I know people who realize that all is not lost.
So as sad and as frustrating as this all is I’m looking at you. The do gooders who actually do something good.
As for me, I’m digging deep and trying to uncover the real reason for this trip and my purpose in it. And I think part of that purpose begins with always looking out the window.
No matter how bad it is.
Mom says
It does make me ashamed and feeling guilty. I see none of this in Brigham, of course. But I do remember our sharing water with a dog in Egypt. Why can I do?
L t says
I help people in my community of Puerto Vallarta each & every day. I actually put my “helping” into my monthly budget & always do more. I do look into people’s eyes be it on the bus or walking & think about what their situation may be.. I always give a smile or some pesos. The people here in Mexico are my friends & that’s how I treat my friends ❤️
Cate Brubaker says
YOU are who I’m praising in this piece. Thanks for reading and thanks for doing what you do to make PV a better place.
Kimber says
Thanks for writing this!
Cate Brubaker says
Thanks for reading.
Digitalis says
*There’s nothing wrong with helping animals, too, of course.
Cate Brubaker says
Of course there isn’t. If I could fit all the dogs in our camper I’d do it in a heartbeat. Thanks for reading!
Zoe says
Thank you for writing this!
Jennifer Sparks says
I think that this is your best post to date. You hit the nail on the head!
Cate Brubaker says
Wow! Thanks Jen! That means a lot coming from you!
Maddy says
Resonates so much! Thank you for sharing! Wish there were easy answers.
Cate Brubaker says
Me too. It also doesn’t help that I’m an empath. I want everyone to be cared for and loved. How does one steel a heart?
Jennifer says
You put into words what I have been struggling through for months. We are on a RTW trip with our 9 & 10 year olds and have had similar thought processes. We want our kids to think about kids in other cultures, their lives, what they fight for or need, to understand above all else that it’s not pity but compassion that is one of the best values we can carry. I’m an empath as well and much of the things we have seen hurt my heart but one of the biggest things I worry about is looking away. I’m struggling to with having so much disgust for the superficial attitudes of many friends back home when I see them posting decisions for new cars or house items that I know could put in a water or septic system in some of the villages we have been in. Not to mention having just been through Vietnam and Cambodia and absorbing the destruction and genocide that so many experienced. (Which still baffles me that this happened in our lifetime). I don’t know how we change but I totally understand the path you are on. Beautifully written.
Cate Brubaker says
Hi Jennifer! Thanks for reading and for your comment. I’m glad you were able to connect with my ideas; they’ve become very important to me. We’re not traveling with children but if we were I’d hope that I’d encourage them like you are. Pity is not the answer; it solves nothing. But privilege can also go two ways. Perhaps because your children have the privilege of this trip they’ll grow up into the problem solvers of this world. Thanks again for reading and happy travels!
Rhonda says
Oh Cate.. these words so hit home. Today, as I sit in comfortable Los Barriles it is easier to forget some of what we have seen these last 14 months, along with our last 25 years of traveling the world. It is so easy to look away or pretend you don’t see the scenes you describe. I admit to getting angry that a local continues to try to sell me something I’ve said no to 3 times. Or 10 times. Even though I have also probably driven past his house and know life is a daily struggle. I am often at a loss because, as you are, we are privileged enough to be driving the world, and yet still consider ourselves poor in the American sense of the word. Sigh… the only thing that does help is our time spent volunteering (for the puppies or the people) and the knowledge that there are people out there fighting the good fight.
Cate Brubaker says
I knew you’d understand. It’s easy to separate yourself while traveling but as you know driving is a far different experience. I just wish i had the words to answer my own questions.
Rhonda says
well, if we had the answers maybe it would be a better world 🙁 Greed and consumerism and money tend to be all-consuming.
Cavalier says
Honduras is poor because it’s full of Hondurans. To make Honduras rich, simply replace the Hondurans with somebody else—Germans, perhaps, or Danes, or Dutchmen. How long shall we tarry? How much suffering must we witness before resolving to bring civilization to such a heinously uncultivated tropical gem? Foreclose already, and let the cleansing remedy begin.